Critical Friends Groups: The Possibilities and Limitations Embedded in Teacher Professional Communities Aimed at Instructional Improvement and School Reform
ARTICLE
Marnie Willis Curry
Teachers College Record Volume 110, Number 4, ISSN 0161-4681
Abstract
Background/Context: This study builds upon research on teacher professional communities and high school restructuring reforms. It employs a conceptual framework that draws upon theories of "community of practice" and "community of learners." Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study: This study analyzes how teachers' professional inquiry communities at the high school level constitute a resource for school reform and instructional improvement. Setting: This research focused on a reforming, comprehensive urban public high school with site-based management. Population/Participants/ Subjects: This study investigates the practices of six school-based oral inquiry groups known as Critical Friends Groups (CFGs), which were selected as cases of mature professional communities. Twenty-five teachers and administrators participated as informants. Research Design: This research involved a video-based, qualitative case study. Data Collection and Analysis: Data included observations of CFG meetings, interviews with teachers and administrators, and document collection. Analysis entailed coding with qualitative software, development of analytic cross-CFG meta-matrices, discourse analytic techniques, and joint viewing of video records with informants. Findings/Results: The author explores four particular design features of CFGs--their diverse menu of activities, their decentralized structure, their interdisciplinary membership, and their reliance on structured conversation tools called "protocols"--showing how these features carry within them endemic tensions that compel these professional communities to negotiate a complicated set of professional development choices. Conclusions/Recommendations: The findings demonstrate how the enactment of design choices holds particular consequences for the nature and quality of teacher learning and school improvement. Although CFGs enhanced teachers' collegial relationships, their awareness of research-based practices and reforms, their schoolwide knowledge, and their capacity to undertake instructional improvement, these professional communities offered an inevitably partial combination of supports for teacher professional development. In particular, CFGs exerted minimal influence on teachers' pedagogical content knowledge. CFGs would benefit from regular and systematic metacognitive and process-oriented reflections to identify how their collaborative practices might optimally advance their "bottom line" goal of improving teacher practice to increase student achievement. Additionally, high schools might pursue multiple and complementary CFG-like professional development opportunities in subject matter departments and interdisciplinary grade-level academy teams.
Citation
Curry, M.W. (2008). Critical Friends Groups: The Possibilities and Limitations Embedded in Teacher Professional Communities Aimed at Instructional Improvement and School Reform. Teachers College Record, 110(4), 733-774. Retrieved August 11, 2024 from https://www.learntechlib.org/p/106058/.
ERIC is sponsored by the Institute of Education Sciences (IES) of the U.S. Department of Education.
Copyright for this record is held by the content creator. For more details see ERIC's copyright policy.
Keywords
- administrators
- case studies
- communities of practice
- Discussion Groups
- Educational Change
- Group Dynamics
- High Schools
- inquiry
- Instructional Improvement
- Interviews
- Meetings
- Pedagogical Content Knowledge
- professional development
- Program Effectiveness
- School Based Management
- School Restructuring
- Secondary School Teachers
- Urban Schools
- Urban Teaching
- Video Technology
Cited By
View References & Citations Map-
Leveraging Analysis of Students’ Disciplinary Thinking in a Video Club to Promote Student-Centered Science Instruction
Tara Barnhart, California State University, Fullerton, United States; Elizabeth van Es, University of California, Irvine, United States
Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education Vol. 18, No. 1 (March 2018) pp. 50–80
These links are based on references which have been extracted automatically and may have some errors. If you see a mistake, please contact info@learntechlib.org.