Are Two Heads Always Better than One? Differential Effects of Collaboration on Students' Computer-Supported Learning in Mathematics
IJCCL Volume 6, Number 3, ISSN 1556-1607
While some studies found positive effects of collaboration on student learning in mathematics, others found none or even negative effects. This study evaluates whether the varying impact of collaboration can be explained by differences in the type of knowledge that is promoted by the instruction. If the instructional material requires students to reason with mathematical concepts, collaboration may increase students' learning outcome as it promotes mutual elaboration. If, however, the instructional material is focused on practicing procedures, collaboration may result in task distribution and thus reduce practice opportunities necessary for procedural skill fluency. To evaluate differential influences of collaboration, we compared four conditions: individual vs. collaborative learning with conceptual instructional material, and individual vs. collaborative learning with procedural instructional material. The instruction was computer-supported and provided adaptive feedback. We analyzed the effect of the conditions on several levels: Logfiles of students' problem-solving actions and video-recordings enabled a detailed analysis of performance and learning processes during instruction. In addition, a post-test assessed individual knowledge acquisition. We found that collaboration improved performance during the learning phase in both the conceptual and the procedural condition; however, conceptual and procedural material had a differential effect on the quality of student collaboration: Conceptual material promoted mutual elaboration; procedural material promoted task distribution and ineffective learning behaviors. Consequently, collaboration positively influenced conceptual knowledge acquisition, while no positive effect on procedural knowledge acquisition was found. We discuss limitations of our study, address methodological implications, and suggest practical implications for the school context.
Mullins, D., Rummel, N. & Spada, H. (2011). Are Two Heads Always Better than One? Differential Effects of Collaboration on Students' Computer-Supported Learning in Mathematics. International Journal of Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, 6(3), 421-443.
- Comparative Analysis
- Computer Assisted Instruction
- Cooperative learning
- Educational Strategies
- Feedback (Response)
- Instructional Effectiveness
- intelligent tutoring systems
- Learning Processes
- Mathematical Concepts
- Mathematics Instruction
- Mathematics Tests
- problem solving
- Video Technology
Cited ByView References & Citations Map
A systematic review of teacher guidance during collaborative learning in primary and secondary education
Anouschka van Leeuwen & Jeroen Janssen
Educational Research Review Vol. 27, No. 1 (June 2019) pp. 71–89
These links are based on references which have been extracted automatically and may have some errors. If you see a mistake, please contact firstname.lastname@example.org.