To TxT or Not to TxT: That’s the Puzzle
Tiong-Thye Goh, Val Hooper, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand
JITE-Research Volume 6, Number 1, ISSN 1539-3585 Publisher: Informing Science Institute
This paper describes the potential use of a mobile phone Short Message Service (SMS) crossword puzzle system to promote interaction through learning activities in a large classroom environment. While personal response systems (PRS) have been used in the classroom environment to foster interaction, it is not an ideal tool with respect to cost and functionality. These limitations prompted the need for an alternative solution. An SMS crossword puzzle system was thus devised. The system consists of two parts: modem software to interface with mobile phones and a database application to generate puzzles, track users’ input, and display an updated puzzle view. A pilot evaluation was conducted with three main objectives in mind. Firstly, the evaluation intended to determine the motivational potential of the puzzle by assessing the significance of the factors that comprise the constructs of learner motivation. Secondly, the evaluation intended to identify any differences in motivational factors between a first and a third year class. Finally, the evaluation intended to assess the potential of behavioral intention to use/play the SMS crossword puzzle in the future. The pilot evaluation also sought to identify areas for improvement and to prepare for future full scale evaluation of the SMS crossword puzzle system. The SMS crossword puzzle was used in two undergraduate information systems classes: a first year foundation course class and a third year elective course class. Each class had a separate puzzle to play with a different set of clues. In the subsequent evaluation, participants of Group 1 consist of 10 students from the first year class, and participants of Group 2 consist of 15 students from the third year class. The instrument used in the evaluation was a survey adopted from Keller’s (1987) studies on motivation theory. Using a 5-point Likert scale, the items covered the motivation factors of attention, relevance, confidence and satisfaction. A single item construct was used to assess the behavioral intention to use. The findings show that students from the first year class found the SMS crossword puzzle much more interesting (attention factor) than students from the third year class, while the third year class found the puzzle neither easy nor difficult to play (confidence factor). With regard to the other components of the motivational factors, no significant difference between the two groups was found. Overall the mean scores were significantly above the mean scale score (>3). Both groups showed significant interest in playing the game in the future, signaling the possibility of adoption. The evaluation also identified SMS latency as being an issue in deploying SMS for near real-time interactive activities. However, the issue can be resolved with distributed architecture and collaboration with a telecom operator or by deploying normalizing strategies to overcome the bottleneck. Finally, the SMS crossword puzzle should be treated as part of a unified service of deploying SMS technology in an educational environment for services such as voting, quizzes, discussion forums, notification of due dates of assignments, examination results, and library services.
Goh, T.T. & Hooper, V. (2007). To TxT or Not to TxT: That’s the Puzzle. Journal of Information Technology Education: Research, 6(1), 441-453. Informing Science Institute.
ReferencesView References & Citations Map
These references have been extracted automatically and may have some errors. Signed in users can suggest corrections to these mistakes.Suggest Corrections to References